A red square with the word speak in white letters on it.
A speech bubble with an orange border on a white background.

Lessons and Takeaways from the 2024 PayPal Brand Refresh

Jason Anthony • October 3, 2024
SHARE THIS:

A brand refresh can be an essential strategy for technology companies aiming to stay competitive and relevant, as demonstrated by PayPal’s recent visual identity update. This move underscores a key principle that we embrace at our agency: differentiating through color while remaining aware of market dynamics and customer expectations.

The power of color in a competitive market


In PayPal’s case, their bold shift from the traditional blue to black for the wordmark signals more than just a cosmetic change; it reflects a strategic repositioning. Blue, a color long associated with trust and stability, is widely used in the financial technology sector. However, with so many companies adopting similar hues, there’s a risk of blending in rather than standing out. By moving to black—a color often linked to sophistication, power, and modernity—PayPal is signaling a new chapter that emphasizes confidence and leadership in the digital payment space. This decision aligns with the best practice of conducting thorough competitive analysis when planning a brand refresh.


As part of our methodology, Speak! analyzes the color palettes of competitors and adjacent market players before embarking on a visual identity update. It’s not just about picking a color that “looks good,” but about choosing one that resonates with your target audience while setting you apart from others in the industry. For technology brands, this might mean stepping away from traditional tech blues and greens and exploring more daring colors that speak to innovation, creativity, or customer-centricity.


It's worth noting that you'll still see plenty of blue used in the PayPay identity system, according to Pentagram:


"The colors have been calibrated for continuous contrast, to create a sense of depth and dimension in the layers of the logo that were not previously there. Bright blue and deep blue overlap to reveal Venmo blue, a nod to the growing mobile app owned by PayPal." 

Application of PayPal’s color palette. Image: Pentagram

Beyond color: what makes a brand refresh successful?


Color alone isn’t enough, of course. PayPal’s refresh involved subtle refinements to the wordmark and logo, signaling an evolution rather than a complete overhaul. This is a key lesson in maintaining brand equity while modernizing. A successful brand refresh often involves walking the line between familiarity and innovation. Your customers should still recognize your brand but feel like it's evolved in ways that better meet their current needs and aspirations.



Best practices for a successful refresh include:


1. Start with strategy, Not Design: Before making any visual changes, brands must understand why they are refreshing their identity. Is it to appeal to a new demographic? Signal a change in business direction? Enhance digital legibility? A clear strategy should guide every creative decision.

 

2. Listen to your audience: Brands that excel in refreshes often tap into consumer insights. How do your users perceive your brand today? What emotions or values do you want your new visual identity to evoke? Aligning design with the feelings and experiences of your customers can significantly enhance brand loyalty.

 

3. Keep it simple: Overly complex logos and intricate design elements can become dated quickly. Simplicity, on the other hand, tends to have staying power. A streamlined visual identity is not only easier for customers to remember, but it also works better across digital platforms—whether on a mobile app, website, or social media.

 

4. Test for flexibility: A modern visual identity must be adaptable. Technology brands, in particular, need logos and colors that are versatile across various formats and channels. From websites and app icons to wearables and product packaging, your visual identity needs to be robust enough to work in different sizes, textures, and environments.

 

5. Create a comprehensive system: Successful brands don’t just change their logo — they create a comprehensive visual system that includes typography, iconography, imagery, and even sound. These elements work together to convey a consistent message. In PayPal’s case, the brand refresh included a refined wordmark and logo, ensuring that all elements of their identity work harmoniously.

The evolution of PayPal’s logo. Image: PayPal

Learning from PayPal: The role of visual identity in brand evolution


Technology companies, especially those in fast-evolving sectors like fintech, often find themselves needing to update their visual identity to stay current. PayPal’s shift reflects their intention to evolve with the times and maintain their leadership in an increasingly crowded space. This balance of continuity and change is critical for long-established brands that want to remain relevant without alienating loyal customers.


When considering a brand refresh, especially for technology companies, we advise looking at broader cultural shifts and industry trends. Technology moves fast, and brands need to evolve at the same pace. However, visual identity changes shouldn’t be driven solely by trends; they must align with the long-term vision and mission of the company.


One of the most compelling aspects of PayPal’s refresh is how it signals change while retaining brand equity. The refreshed logo isn’t drastically different from its predecessor, ensuring that the brand remains instantly recognizable. This speaks to a broader best practice: evolution, not revolution. Unless there’s a dramatic shift in your business model or offering, subtle, thoughtful changes often have the most impact. Customers appreciate brands that evolve with them, but too much change at once can feel jarring or inauthentic.



The value of a thoughtful brand refresh


PayPal’s brand refresh exemplifies the power of visual identity updates done right. By analyzing competitive trends and using color strategically, PayPal managed to distinguish itself while maintaining its core identity. For technology brands, the lessons here are clear: invest time in understanding your market, listen to your customers, and create a visual identity system that not only reflects who you are today but will continue to resonate in the future.


At Speak!, we champion this approach — carefully balancing creativity with strategy to ensure that a brand refresh not only makes a company look good but also supports its business goals. As a creative and brand agency for technology companies, we believe by focusing on differentiation, simplicity, and flexibility, tech brands can use visual identity to strengthen emotional connections with their audience, leading to greater loyalty and long-term success.

How AI Agents Are Transforming Marketing & Sales Alignment

By Speak Agency • February 13, 2025
Marketing and sales are supposed to work in sync. Marketing creates the messaging, sales takes it to market, and customers get a consistent, compelling brand experience. But in reality? That almost never happens.

MVB: What Early-Stage Tech Brands Need to Launch a Minimum Viable Brand

By Speak Agency • February 10, 2025
For tech startups, creating a Minimum Viable Product (MVP) — the stripped-down version of your product that allows you to test core assumptions with real users — is a common approach to product development. But what about your brand? Enter the Minimum Viable Brand (MVB): the essential elements needed to present your company professionally and connect with early customers, without over-investing in elaborate brand development.

The Truth, The Whole Truth, And Nothing But the Truth. So Help Your Brand.

By Speak Agency • February 3, 2025
Let's cut to the chase: In a world drowning in digital noise and AI-generated content, brand authenticity isn't just a nice-to-have — it's your survival kit. Today's tech-savvy customers can smell manufactured messaging from ten browser tabs away, and they're not afraid to hit "unfollow" faster than you can say "corporate values." The Power of Brand Truth Here's the deal: brand authenticity means getting real about who you are as an organization. We're not talking about your product specs or your tech stack — we're talking about the raw, honest truth of why you exist and what drives your team to show up every day. Your brand truth might be buried in your startup story, your unique approach to solving gnarly problems, or the way you're fundamentally changing how your customers work and live. Take Microsoft's transformation under Satya Nadella. When he took the reins in 2014, he didn't just pivot the company's technology — he unleashed its authentic truth as an enabler of human achievement. This wasn't some slick marketing play; it was a fundamental shift from "Windows first" to "empower every person and organization on the planet to achieve more." The result? Microsoft's stock price soared over 600% since 2014, and they've become one of the most valuable companies in the world. Why Truth Matters More Than Ever The numbers don't lie: According to Stackla, 88% of consumers say authenticity is crucial when deciding which brands to support. Even more telling? A recent Edelman study found that 81% of consumers need to trust a brand before they'll even consider buying from them. In an age where every startup claims to be "disrupting" something, customers are developing highly sophisticated BS detectors. They're not just looking at your product dashboard — they're scrutinizing your GitHub contributions, reading your engineering blog posts, and watching how you handle service outages on Twitter. Uncovering Your Brand's Truth Finding your brand's authentic truth requires serious introspection. Ask yourself: What technical problem made you angry enough to start this company? What conventional wisdom in your industry are you willing to challenge? What keeps showing up in your customer success stories? What principles would you defend even if they slowed down your growth? Sometimes your truth is hiding in plain sight. Look at Twilio. Their brand truth isn't about APIs — it's about democratizing complex communications technology. This core truth drives everything from their developer-first approach to their acquisition strategy. Expressing Truth Through Story Once you've nailed your brand truth, you need to tell its story in a way that clicks with your audience. And no, we're not talking about another "Our Journey" blog post. Consider how Stripe tells its story. Their truth isn't about payment processing — it's about increasing the GDP of the internet. This bigger narrative has turned what could have been dry technical documentation into a compelling story about empowering entrepreneurs worldwide. Their transparency about their engineering challenges and public infrastructure investments has built unprecedented trust in the developer community. Building Trust Through Consistency Real talk: authenticity means walking the walk. When Zoom faced security criticisms in 2020, CEO Eric Yuan didn't hide behind PR speak. He admitted the problems, implemented a 90-day feature freeze to focus on security, and hosted weekly webinars to address concerns. This transparent approach turned a potential crisis into a trust-building opportunity. The data backs this up: According to PwC, 71% of consumers say they'll lose trust in a brand if they perceive it's putting profit over people. And once that trust is gone, 46% say they'll stop buying from the company altogether. The Bottom Line In the tech world, where every other company claims to be "revolutionary" or "game-changing," authentic brand truth is your secret weapon. It's not about crafting the perfect message—it's about having the courage to be genuinely, consistently, unapologetically you. The next generation of successful tech brands won't win because they had the most sophisticated tech stack or the biggest AWS budget. They'll win because they dared to be real in an increasingly artificial world. In an industry obsessed with automation and scalability, never forget that authenticity is the one thing you can't fake. Remember: Your brand truth is like your source code — you don't write it from scratch, you refactor and optimize what's already there. When you commit to pushing authentic commits to your brand repository, you're not just building a better story — you're compiling a more resilient business that resonates with users on a fundamental level.
SHOW MORE
Share by: